Last night’s Teen Mom finale was especially gut-wrenching as Tyler and Catelynn drove to West Virginia to see Carly, the daughter they gave up for adoption one year ago.
Of all the diverse situations depicted on Teen Mom, Catelynn and Tyler’s experience is truly unique. We’ve seen various angles on adoption before with Oprah uniting long lost parents with their adopted children, and movie-of-the-week scenes of tearful teen mothers reluctantly handing over their swaddled bundle to a stern nurse. However, the risky decision to focus on Catelynn and Tyler’s feelings in the year following the adoption taps into something unspoken and bordering on taboo.
Adoption gets conveniently packaged as a selfless, responsible, and noble decision for ill-prepared parents to make. Over the past season of Teen Mom, Catelynn and Tyler’s choice to put Carly up for adoption created serious inter-family conflict, feelings of vacillating regret, crippling emptiness, and deep depression for both. Adoption is generally credited as a panacea for the accompanying ills of unintended pregnancy, but Catelynn and Tyler’s journey challenged this assumption since (despite giving up Carly), neither graduated high school on time.
At the heart-breaking picnic in the park, Catelynn learned Carly scrunches her nose just like she did when she was a baby, and Tyler and Carly share the same eyes and appetite. There even seemed to be a primal recognition between Carly and her biological parents when each held her for the first time in a year.
In looking at the bleak circumstances of other Teen Mom spawn, Leah, Sophia, and Bentley, no doubt, Carly is growing up in a better place (if that can ever be said about West Virginia), but there was also something innately tragic about watching Tyler and Catelynn kiss their baby girl goodbye.
Catelynn and Tyler’s honesty about their deep sense of loss and longing for Carly has inadvertently cast them as the anti-adoption adoption poster children.
Ultimately, the couple expressed a sense of peace over their choice, but anyone who tuned in this season knows it has been a long hard road to reach this place of acceptance. Whether they realize it or not, Catelynn and Tyler have quietly revolutionized the adoption conversation by revealing that adoption isn’t always the neat and tidy solution it is painted to be.